About Everything2
Everything2 is a good idea in principle.
It's a user-created "open source" encyclopedia that borrows a lot
from Douglas Adams' Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy. Users fill out
little pockets of knowledge based on their areas of expertise. One of the
problems with the initial version of the Everything guide was there was no
real oversight over what was being entered into the guide. The guide began
to get loaded down with too many entries like "Let me tell you about
my big dick" or "Why the Detroit Lions suck this year".
The Everything concept was
recast as Everything2. Quality control is helped along by allowing users to
cast votes (up votes or down votes) on other people's entries. Entries that
cross some threshold of "down votes" come to the attention of
editors who can delete entries. If your entry gets voted up, you get
"experience points". As you add entries and gain experience
points, you get increased user privileges (additional "powers").
Unfortunately, people do
not always vote based on the actual quality of the nodes. As in all shared
human endeavors, Everything2 users get to know each other. Some users get
along. Others don't. Some fall in love. Some don't like who others are
falling in love with. Down votes and up votes end up getting cast for
reasons other than quality of the actual entry authored.
Another problem arises
from something called "soft linking". The entry author can, of
course, create hypertext links from his/her entry to other areas of the
guide. However, readers can themselves create hypertext links in a sort of
"see also" section beneath the entry. These are called "soft
links". Everything2 users quickly figured out they could add soft
links as a form of commentary on the entry or the author. It's not uncommon
to see soft links like "slut", "whore", or
"bitch" added to the bottom of a female user. Yes, real mature.
Worse, some editors began
to turn Everything2 into a dumping ground for their short stories, poems,
and literary "experiments" while at the same time deleting the
entries of the "lowly" users who mistakenly thought they could
emulate the behavior of the editors. The original intent of Everything, an
open source encyclopedia, has been forgotten by some of the people charged
with keeping things like "Let me tell you about my big dick" out
of the guide. The editors, given power to delete nodes, suspend accounts,
and edit other's work, began to refer to themselves as "gods". As
a nod to modesty, the editors prefer the lower case g variant of
"god".
For a time editors kept a
public log of what entries they were deleting, along with a reason why the
contribution was deleted. I found this a reasonable check-and-balance on
their power. It was also educational for users, teaching them what was
acceptable and what was not. Users could see that even long-time,
experienced users got material deleted. It helped users see they were not
being picked on. However, after a time, editors stopped making any attempt
at justifying their actions. It seems they prefer the exercising of power
over the exercising of responsibility.
It appeared to me some of
these self-styled gods came to think of Everything2 as existing as a big
favor to users, when the relationship is two ways. After contributing about
1,300 entries to Everything2, I grew tired of the pettiness and uneven
application of editorial control and left. However, I archived about 450 of
my favorite Everything2 entries. At right are some of my favorites.
|
Topics
TV
v Corinthian Leather
v Helsinki Formula
v I Can't Believe I Ate the
Whole Thing
v It's not nice to fool
Mother Nature
v Queen For A Day
. . .
Fast Food
v Deep Fried Mars Bar
v Where's Herb?
v White Castle Hamburgers
. . .
Computer History
v Asteroids
v Computerland
v CTRL+ALT+DEL
v David Crane
v Donkey Kong
v DOS: A history by the
numbers
v E.T. The Extra Terrestrial
for the Atari 2600
v Frogger
v Heath Kits
v History of Epyx
v Ozark Softscape: Creators
of M.U.L.E.
v Richard Garriott (AKA Lord
British)
v The Rise and Fall of
Infocom
v Scott Adams
v SoftRAM Scam
v West Coast Computer Faire
. . .
Geeky History
v Dave Arneson
v Finieous Fingers
v Gary Gygax
v History of GenCon
v James Dallas Egbert III
v Wormy
. . .
Pop History
v Earthshoes
v Pop-Tarts
v Snapple
. . .
Just History
v Cosmos 954
v Fritz Haber
v Tonton Macoutes
. . .
Just Whatever
v Canadian Bank Notes
v Devil Went Down to Georgia
v How To Approach a Developer who may well be
Working and Ask Him a Question
v How Zeller's Club Z Ruined My Life
. . .
|